Hayward, Pentair or Jandy: Which Salt Cell Is Right for Your Pool?

If you're shopping for a salt chlorination system — whether you're replacing a dead cell or starting fresh — three brands are going to keep coming up: Hayward, Pentair, and Jandy. All three make quality products, but they're not built for the same situation. Pool size, whether you already have a system installed, and budget all play a role in which one makes the most sense for you. At Aqua Pool Supply, we carry all three brands for in-ground pools and price them competitively — so this guide is here to cut through the confusion and help you make the right call the first time.

One thing worth saying upfront: if you already have a salt system installed and just need a new cell, brand compatibility matters. Hayward, Pentair, and Jandy cells are not cross-compatible — they each require their own brand's controller and power center. So if your system is still functional and only the cell has worn out (typically every 3–7 years), your decision is already mostly made. The goal at that point is just finding the best price on the right cell — and we've got you covered there too.

Quick Comparison: At a Glance

Here's a fast look at the three systems before we get into the details on each:

• Jandy Pro Series TruClear Cell (R0693900) — Replacement cell only, up to 35,000 gallons, $479.94 — lowest price online right now
• Hayward AquaRite w/TurboCell (W3AQR9) — Complete system (controller + TurboCell included), up to 25,000 gallons, $1,999.00
• Pentair IntelliChlor Plus40 (523735-EC) — Replacement cell only, up to 40,000 gallons, $1,819.00 (reg. $2,000.00)

The most important distinction here: the Hayward AquaRite is a complete system — it includes both the controller and the TurboCell. The Jandy and Pentair options are replacement cells only and require a compatible power center already in place. Keep that in mind as you read through each section.

Jandy Pro Series TruClear Replacement Cell — R0693900

Best For: Existing Jandy TruClear System Owners — and the Best Budget Value Right Now

If you already have a Jandy TruClear chlorine generating system, the Jandy R0693900 TruClear Cell is your direct replacement. It's a genuine OEM part rated for pools up to 35,000 gallons and plugs directly into your existing Jandy power center — no new hardware, no additional cost. The cell handles the full chlorination cycle automatically, converting dissolved salt into chlorine and then back again to keep your water consistently sanitized.

What makes this one stand out right now is the price. At $479.94, it's one of the lowest prices you'll find online for this cell — most retailers are running $550–$650 or more. If your Jandy system is working fine and the cell has simply reached the end of its life, this is a straightforward, cost-effective fix that gets you back up and running without overpaying.

Key Specs

• Pool Type: In-ground
• Pool Capacity: Up to 35,000 gallons
• What's Included: Replacement cell only (requires existing Jandy TruClear controller)
• Part Number: R0693900
• OEM: Genuine Jandy part — not aftermarket

What to Know

This is a cell-only replacement — it does not include a controller or power center. It's the budget-friendly pick of the three and the right call for any Jandy system owner whose cell has worn out. In stock and ready to ship.

Our Price: $479.94 — Lowest Price Online

Hayward AquaRite Salt Chlorinator with TurboCell — W3AQR9

Best For: New In-Ground Pool Installations or Full System Replacements

The Hayward AquaRite W3AQR9 is the most complete package in this comparison. Unlike the Jandy and Pentair options, this is a full system — the AquaRite controller and the TurboCell are both included in the box. If you're switching from traditional chlorine for the first time, replacing an entire aging salt system, or your old controller and cell both need to go, the AquaRite W3AQR9 covers everything in one purchase.

The TurboCell technology inside this system is what Hayward built their salt chlorination reputation on — efficient chlorine output with a long cell lifespan. The digital display gives you adjustable chlorine output from 0–100% and the system operates within a salinity range of 2,700–3,400 ppm. It's a well-rounded system that's been widely installed in residential pools for years, and the support network (replacement cells, service parts) is solid.

Hayward also offers a 40,000-gallon version if your pool exceeds 25,000 gallons. You can browse the full Hayward salt system lineup to find the right size for your pool.

Key Specs

• Pool Type: In-ground
• Pool Capacity: Up to 25,000 gallons
• What's Included: AquaRite controller + TurboCell (complete system)
• Chlorine Output: Adjustable 0–100%
• Salinity Range: 2,700–3,400 ppm
• Display: Digital with real-time monitoring
• SKU: W3AQR9

What to Know

Because this is a complete system, it's naturally priced higher than a cell-only replacement — but you're getting both the controller and the cell together. If you're already running a functioning Hayward power center and only need a replacement TurboCell, check the individual TurboCell options in our Hayward lineup instead. In stock and ships fast.

Our Price: $1,999.00

Pentair IntelliChlor Plus40 Salt Cell — 523735-EC

Best For: Existing Pentair System Owners and Those Who Want the Most Advanced Cell Available

The Pentair IntelliChlor Plus40 is the current-generation replacement for the widely-used IC40, which has been discontinued. If you've been searching for an IC40 replacement — this is it. It's a direct drop-in for existing IC40 and iChlor installations with zero replumbing required, and it's fully compatible with Pentair's EasyTouch, IntelliTouch, and IntelliCenter automation systems.

Beyond being the right replacement for Pentair owners, the Plus40 is a genuinely upgraded product. Pentair redesigned it with a modular structure that makes sensor replacement about 50% faster, and added a redesigned conductivity sensor for highly accurate salt level readings. The display shows over 20 built-in diagnostic indicators — more system visibility than most cells on the market. It also ships with an acid cleaning kit for scale prevention built right in. For those in the Greater Phoenix area, this product comes with free installation and a 3-year warranty — ask us about that when you order.

Rated for pools up to 40,000 gallons, it's also the highest-capacity cell in this comparison.

Key Specs

• Pool Type: In-ground
• Pool Capacity: Up to 40,000 gallons
• What's Included: Plus40 replacement cell, acid cleaning kit, installation guide
• Compatibility: Direct replacement for IC40 and iChlor; works with EasyTouch, IntelliTouch, IntelliCenter
• Diagnostics: 20+ built-in LCD/LED indicators
• Part Number: 523735-EC
• OEM: Genuine Pentair part

What to Know

This is a replacement cell only — it requires an existing Pentair power center or compatible automation system. It's the premium pick in this comparison, and at $1,819.00 it reflects that. But if you're running a Pentair system and want the most capable, diagnostic-rich cell available, this is the right investment. Low stock — only 2 remaining.

Regular Price: $2,000.00  |  Our Price: $1,819.00  |  Instant Savings: $181.00

So Which One Should You Choose?

If Your Salt Cell Died and Your System Still Works

Match your brand and replace the cell. Salt cells are brand-specific — Hayward, Pentair, and Jandy cells require their own brand's controller. If you have a Jandy TruClear system, the R0693900 at $479.94 is your best bet and one of the best prices online right now. If you have Pentair, the IntelliChlor Plus40 is the current replacement for the IC40. If you're running a Hayward system and need just a TurboCell, check the individual cell options in our Hayward lineup.

If You're Installing a New Salt System from Scratch

The Hayward AquaRite W3AQR9 is the most straightforward option — controller and TurboCell included, no separate purchases needed, and Hayward's AquaRite platform is one of the most widely used and serviced residential salt systems in the country. If you're leaning toward Pentair or Jandy for a new install, those brands typically sell complete systems separately — give us a call and we can point you in the right direction.

If Your Whole System — Controller and Cell — Is Done

Same answer as above: the Hayward AquaRite W3AQR9 gives you both in one box. It also comes down to what ecosystem you want to be in long-term. Pentair owners tend to stay Pentair because of automation integration. Jandy owners do the same. If you're starting with a clean slate and don't have a preference, Hayward is a proven, well-supported choice at a competitive price.

If Budget Is the Main Factor

The Jandy TruClear R0693900 at $479.94 is the clear value leader right now — especially if you're replacing a cell on an existing Jandy system. It's a genuine OEM part at a price that's hard to match anywhere online.

Still Not Sure? We Can Help.

Questions about which system fits your pool or your existing setup? Give us a call or stop by — we have locations in Phoenix, Chandler, Scottsdale, and Las Vegas. Our team handles salt system questions every day and can help you match the right product without the guesswork. You can also browse the full lineup of salt systems and chlorine generators we carry across all three brands.